Soft morning light on an espresso counter and a small shelf of everyday provisions in a welcoming neighborhood shop.

Why Mott's Market Still Has to Sell Paper Towels Next to the Espresso Bar

  • November 12, 2026

A model train runs along the crown molding at Mott's Market. Peyton Sherwood found it at a big train show in York, Pennsylvania, and installed it himself with custom track and truss. According to Hill Rag's June report on the reopening, it runs on a schedule or when someone pushes a button, and it has turned out to be at least as popular with adults as with children.

Below the train, a few steps from a Counter Culture espresso bar, are shelves of canned beans, diapers, trash bags, and paper towels. The neighbors who own the building at 233 12th St. SE, just south of Lincoln Park, made the grocery a condition of the lease. The rest of the store, including the sandwiches, the wine list, and the patio, is arranged to pay for that shelf.

The clause that keeps the grocery shelf

When neighbors formed Mott's Neighborhood Market LLC to buy the building, they put a rule in the operating agreement: whoever holds the lease has to keep a market in the space. LLC president Michael Skinner explained the goal to City Cast DC. The point was to "future-proof and save this as a community asset."

Sherwood agreed to keep both the name and the grocery. He also told City Cast why a grocery can't support the space by itself. Grocery margins are thin, and small corner stores have a harder time than supermarket chains and big-box stores getting fair wholesale prices. Coffee, wine, and sandwiches, he said, would pay the bills.

So the store works on a simple trade. The café makes the money that the grocery shelf can't make on its own.

What is on the counter, and what is on the shelf

Sherwood calls the store "small but mighty," according to Hill Rag. On the retail side, he deliberately stocks the kind of everyday brands "you'll find at 7-Eleven too" next to better pantry staples like "really nice olive oils." The idea is that neighbors can pick up what they need without a trip to a big grocery store. Hill Rag's August 9 review also listed produce, sodas, spices, cereal, snacks, and household products.

Here is what pays for those shelves, based on the menus Hill Rag reported in June and August:

Program What it includes
Coffee Counter Culture drip, plus hot and iced espresso drinks
Cold sandwiches Chicken salad, roast beef, fried eggplant souvlaki with tzatziki, tomato tapenade, cucumber and pickled red onion
Hot sandwiches Chicken parm; Mississippi pot roast with peppercorn roast beef, aged provolone and comeback sauce on a French roll
Breakfast Breakfast burritos, including the chorizo version Hill Rag tried in August
Wine and beer About 80 labels; bottles to drink on-site start around $24, and to-go bottles are 30% off

The wine pricing is where the trade shows up most clearly. A bottle opened at a patio table carries a markup. The same bottle taken home costs 30% less, which Hill Rag described as pulling the price back toward retail. That makes the wine cooler both a bar list and a neighborhood bottle shop. On the store's own site, the list is "more than 80 wines from around the world."

Ordering works two ways. Customers can scan a table QR code for full service, with bottles and sandwiches brought out. Or they can take water and beer from the cooler and go straight to the patio. Hill Rag's August reviewer described the back patio as roomy, shaded by umbrellas, edged with herbs, and pet-friendly. He called the first weeks a "successful and fun shakedown cruise." Eater DC's Capitol Hill guide, updated August 18, added wine Wednesdays and affogatos to the list.

How a corner store took four years to reopen

The grocery requirement explains why the shelf is there. The timeline explains how hard it was to keep any store on this corner at all.

  1. 1916. A corner store opens at the site, according to Hill Rag. The name Mott's came later, from the nickname of a 1960s owner.
  2. March 4, 2022. The Cho family, who ran the store, closes it.
  3. October 2022. The neighbor group buys the building for $1.31 million with a commercial loan.
  4. December 2023. The board names Sherwood, who is also known for St. Vincent Wine in Park View, as the new tenant.
  5. June 2024. Sherwood agrees to the lease terms. His plan removes a wall and staircase that split the space in half, adds an espresso bar and a kitchen in the back, and turns the backyard into a patio.
  6. June 21 to 23, 2026. A soft opening on Sunday, June 21, then regular operations starting Tuesday, June 23.
  7. August 11, 2026. The grand reopening celebration on the renovated patio.

The longest delay came between steps five and six. City Cast reported that permits, conflicting requests from city reviewers, and a new sprinkler system set the project back at least two years. The sprinkler meant digging up and replacing the water main under the street, a line first installed in 1891. Those delays cost hundreds of thousands of dollars that weren't in the budget, so the group took out a line of credit and raised more money.

"It was this labyrinth of red tape that was very difficult for a community-based organization to work through, even with hiring expediters for this," Skinner told City Cast. "If this weren't a group community effort, I could very easily see someone giving up."

A Department of Buildings spokesperson told the outlet that approvals "did take longer than expected due to internal and external factors." DC Water said many of the water main delays were outside its control, including weather and the expiration and renewal of DDOT permits. To keep neighbors involved during the wait, the team hosted art shows, a fall festival, and a "Winter Wonderland" party with Santa and crafts for kids in the empty space.

Who holds the votes

The ownership structure is what makes the grocery clause last. City Cast reported that each $1,000 invested equals one unit vote, and investments run from $5,000 to $50,000. In the grand-reopening announcement Hill Rag published, the LLC says it represents 94 neighborhood-based investors. City Cast counted about 140 people when spouses in each couple are counted separately.

The group is still taking new investors. The store's site describes the offer as a way to keep Mott's "a locally owned gathering place and an enduring part of Capitol Hill." This is general information, not legal or financial advice. Anyone considering an investment should go over the terms with their own attorney or financial advisor.

Built to stay small

Sherwood has kept the store from growing past the size of a neighborhood shop. Hill Rag reported that he chose not to apply for a full entertainment endorsement. He wanted nearby residents to know Mott's would stay a neighborhood operation and not become a nightlife spot.

His June plans followed the same idea: tastings in the backyard, a front patio once permits and staffing allowed, and a soft-serve machine. He also said he wanted to bring back traditions the old Mott's crowd remembers, including the winter market, art shows, Halloween candy, and visits with Santa.

"We would love to be people's third place."

Skinner used similar words with City Cast, which reported that coffee-bar lines in July and families on the patio were early signs the idea was working. The third place at Mott's includes a grocery shelf because the owners' agreement requires one.

The holiday season on the Hill starts a week from Saturday, on November 21 at 5:30 p.m. That's when the Capitol Hill BID holds its 20th annual tree lighting at the "Sonny" tree on Eastern Market Metro Plaza, with performances, hot chocolate, and doughnuts.

At the Hagen Bergstrom Team, we have seen for decades how much a block's corner store adds to daily life on the streets around it. If you own near Lincoln Park and want to talk about what places like Mott's mean for your block, we would be glad to sit down with you. Book an Appointment.

main

Work With Us

Sylvia and Marin specialize in historic and “one and only” properties, luxury homes, condos, co-ops and everything in between. Their business is nearly 100% repeat and referral, a testament to their high ethical standards, strong negotiating skills, energy and discretion.

Follow Us